Towing in France

[rooney]

Can anyone inform me whether it is legal in France and, other European countries, to tow a car using a "A" frame.

We intend to have one of these fitted to our motorhome so that we can tow a small car.

[derf]

I know several people who have done the same thing but I doubt it is legal in France even in the UK they were always a bit dodgy in Law, and you had to meet the requirements for braked trailers and needed to fit a brake to the vehicle on tow, I used to use one sometimes,  to tow broken down vehicles to the garage, it was OK with the older cars but vehicles changed and Modern vehicles with plastic bumpers are not suitable for towing with an A Frame it's far better to use a "Spectacle lift" so the front wheels are off the ground.

If you are towing an A frame on UK plates I doubt that you would be stopped by the police in France, provided that you have a legal trailer lighting board and number plate fitted

[Esperaza]

I've no doubt that some-one will give "chapter & verse" but I believe that the car must have all four wheels off the road on a braked trailer. I also believe that the minimum height of the car wheels above the road is also specified.

The only car that I know of that can be transported on an un-braked trailer is the little Axiam (sp!).

The maximum legal weight of an un-braked trailer is 750kg.

[Quillan]

I have seen these used on those big, coach like, motor homes but none of them have had French number plates. I seem to remember this came up a year or two ago and the responce was that you can't do this in France with a French registered motorhome. I am sure if I am wrong somebody will correc me.

[Anton Redman]

It is and was a matter of debate on the UK Caravan Club Forum and other places. I have never seen a French registered 'Winabago' with a Smart etc on the back.

[Quillan]

I have seen them with cars (small like a Smart) on a breaked trailor and I have seen motorbikes on a platform accros wise attached to the back rather like a bike rack but bigger.

[Esperaza]

With acknowledgements to UK Camping and Tony Maris. Also see http://www.motorcaravanning.co.uk/vehicles/towing.htm     Index : Towing : Towing behind a motorhome. What you should know - by Tony Maris Towing behind a motorhome. What you should know

If you are thinking of fitting a towbar to your motorhome, just check a couple of things before you start. Firstly, do you actually have the spare capacity to do it? If your vehicle handbook does not list a towing limit, have a look at the VIN plate. This should give the Gross Train Weight (the largest figure) followed by the Maximum Gross Weight. Two other figures you would expect to see are Axle Weights. Deduct the MGW from the GTW and the difference would normally be your maximum towing limit. Secondly, check the wheelbase of the vehicle (centre of front axle to centre of rear axle) and then measure the overhang (the distance from the centre of the rear axle to the extreme back). The overhang can go up to 60% of the wheelbase and the towbar needs to fit within this limit. If your vehicle has an Al-Ko chassis, do not allow the fitter to drill extra holes for the towbar mounting. Your chassis warranty would be invalidated. Braked versus unbraked To tow without brakes on the trailer, the Maximum Gross Weight of that trailer must not exceed 750 kgs or half the Kerbside Weight of the towing vehicle, whichever is the least. Unbraked trailers must be clearly marked with the year of manufacture and their Maximum Gross Weight. If built after 1/1.97, they must have a secondary coupling fitted. Braked trailers manufactured after 1968 must have brakes on all wheels. If built after October 1982, an hydraulically damped over-run coupling is required and, if built after April 1989, the trailer must have an auto-reverse brake mechanism which meets the efficiency laid down in EC directive 71/320. Additionally, braked trailers need to have a breakaway cable fitted which is capable of operating the handbrake mechanism if the trailer becomes detached from the towing vehicle, it is an offence not to use it and, it must be ‘securely attached’ to the towing vehicle. It is unlikely that merely looping round the towball would be considered a secure attachment! 'A' frames and Dollies Q. What is a trailer? A. A road vehicle, usually (but not necessarily) two wheeled, towed by a motor vehicle.Given the above dictionary definition, it is fairly clear that anything attached to the towball and having wheels in contact with the ground is a trailer. This includes cars on ‘A’ frames and dollies. Bearing in mind that the unbraked towing limit of 750 kgs refers to Maximum Gross Weight (i.e. the figure on the towed cars VIN plate) and not to actual weight, it severely restricts the options. The only cars I know of with a MGW of less than 750 kgs is the Aixam range. These are around 450 to 550 kgs. There are strict regulations on braked trailers and, whilst a braked ‘A’ frame attached to a towed car constitutes a braked trailer, it is not legal for transportation as it cannot comply with EC71/320. With car dollies, the situation is somewhat different. Under regulation 83 of the Road Vehicles (construction & Use) Regulations 1986 (SI.1986/1078) Amending Regulations, a car dolly, with a car in place, will be considered as two trailers. This is legal for recovery but, under the Road Traffic Regulations Act 1984 (Schedule 6) the combination is limited to 40 mph on motorways and dual carriageways and 20 mph elsewhere. Note that there is a very specific difference between recovery and transportation. Recovery is the removal of a broken down vehicle to a place of safety. It does not include removing a rotor arm (for instance) and travelling the length and breadth of the country. The police are well aware of the difference due to the regulations covering Tachographs and Operators Licences. Recovery vehicles are exempt. It is well known that some countries in the EEC tend to overlook the regulations (the UK included) but some countries don’t. The situation regarding enforcement could change at any time and, as a result, the only safe way to transport another vehicle behind a motorhome is on a car transporter trailer. Play safe! Don’t take the risk! The regulations which cover this aspect of towing are:- 91/438/EEC covers driving licences. 71/320/EEC covers auto reverse braking systems and couplings. S.I. 1971 No 450 Part III covers the obstruction of number plates. 94/20/EEC covers type approval of towing equipment and ‘S’ and ‘D’ values. 95/48/EEC covers Masses and Dimensions of M1 class vehicles. E.T.R.T.O. 1991 section 13 covers wheels and tyres. BSAU 113c covers 50mm ball and coupling dimensions. BSAU 24a (1989) covers eye couplings and pin/jaw arrangements. 98/12/EEC covers brake linings and will be implemented in the UK from 1/4/01.And not strictly towing but applicable to motorhomes is EN1648-1 covers extra low voltage installations in Leisure Vehicles and Caravans. Disclaimer The information in this guide is as accurate as the writer is able to make it, however, no responsibility can be accepted for any inaccuracies which may be in the text. It is the responsibility of any person wishing to depend on the facts to check for themselves with original documentation or any updating regulations, instruments or changes in the law. Interpretation of the law is a matter for the courts.

Index : Towing : Towing behind a motorhome. What you should know - by Tony Maris