Whatever we may think about 'whining Brits' the fact remains that the EU decided France was in breach of EC regulations, and that is why they have been obliged to issue this new circular easing up access into the system (to which of course there is an 8% insurance levy). My own sister was caught up in the change of rules in 2007. Although she had an E106 entitlement, she has an illness that made private insurance impossible. But the local CPAM were unwilling to say that they would give her cover at the expiry of the 106, so she has been forced to remain in the UK, with a house standing empty for three years.