Sprogster
-
Posts
1,377 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Never
Posts posted by Sprogster
-
-
For anyone considering moving to France and finding employment I would strongly suggest they read the reports published this week by the IMF and PwC on the French economy, which make pretty grim reading, saying rather worryingly that France has now economically fallen behind both Spain and Italy to become the sick man of Europe. Furthermore, it is anticipated that France will fall back into recession, with recovery possibly taking 20 years, because of the structural reforms needed to the French labour market that are unlikely to happen anytime soon.Not so much a problem for those of us who have retired or are second home owners, other than continuing falling French house values and increasing taxes, but pause for thought if you need to make a living.By comparison growth in the USA and UK continues to accelerate and even Spain looks like it has turned the corner.
-
The main comment I would make is not France specific but the danger of voluntarily taking yourself out of the job market for twelve months following redundancy.Firstly, the reality is that the current French economic situation is dire and now worse than Spain, with a very recent IMF report warning that France is likely to go back into recession. Therefore, the probability of finding work in France as a foreigner is remote and meanwhile having left the UK one has dramatically reduced the likelihood of finding alternative employment there.Also whilst spending Spring through Autumn in France is one thing, would they really want to spend a long cold dark winter in rural France, where everything tends to shut down. A lot of Brits have a totally misconceived idea as to the French climate and are shocked how cold and wet winters can be there.As for health care, personally I think it is irresponsible moving to France without proper health care coverage especially where children are concerned, which will probably in this situation include some element of private health insurance. As what happens if you are involved in a road accident for example, as you could find yourself with six figure medical bills that the French authorities pursue you back to the UK for.
-
The EU runs a trade surplus with the UK and for countries like France and Germany the UK in many areas of manufacturing is it's biggest single country export market. Therefore, if the UK voted to leave the EU it undoubtedly would be offered the same free trade arrangements as Norway and Switzerland that have all the free trade membership benefits without being a member of the EU. Under these circumstances there would be no economic disadvantage for the foreign car manufacturers maintaining their UK presence.What will probably happen is that the Eurozone countries will move to further political and monetary integration and there will be an outer tier of countries that have the free trade benefits but not be a full member of the EU for political or monetary purposes.That said the Northern European countries like Germany, Scandinavia, Poland and the Netherlands will fight hard to keep the UK in the EU as a political counterweight to the influence of the Mediterranean countries, which would grow without the counterweight of the UK which has the second largest populace of any EU country after Germany and is forecast to shortly overtake France as Europe's second largest economy.
-
Bide your time as French property market and economy continues to weaken, also the £ is forecast to strengthen further against the euro.Also beware if planning to buy apartments to rent in France whilst non French resident, that controversially the French government are imposing social security charges on unfurnished lets owned by non residents. These charges amounting to 15.5 per cent are not recognised as a tax by HMRC or other foreign tax authorities and allowed as a tax credit and you end up being double taxed and get no benefit in France either.
-
Looked at the profile for the OP and found out they have never visited the forum since their initial and only post!Have started to do this with new members before responding to their questions if more than a few days old, as this seems to happen surprisingly frequently.
-
My understanding is that there is an ongoing process in France to bring property valuations up to date for TF assesment purposes, as they had not been increased for many years. As a result it is expected that this will have an additional upward pressure on French property taxes.
-
What probably did not help either is that the UK government inits wisdom decided that the passport issuing offices in the Channel Islands andthe Isle of Man would no longer be able to renew or issue British Island passports,as this would be centralised to a UK mainland passport office. This was despitethe fact the passport offices in Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man had nohistory of passport fraud and were paid for by the Island governments, so therewas no cost saving for the UK Treasury.
-
Tinabee has highlighted a very important consideration in that the tax
residence of a company or business is not determined solely on where itsactivities are based, or in what jurisdiction it is incorporated, but principallywhere the mind and management is located.So in the scenario mentioned by Hagg, if they lived in France, were majority
shareholders, remained on the board and kept in contact by phone or videoconference, then with any one of these factors there is a very stronglikelihood the French tax authorities would take the view that the mind andmanagement of the business was in France.Very important to get appropriate specialised French tax advice, as when
moving to France contact will be made between HMRC and French Fisc, so notsomething you can keep off the radar these days. -
Hagg,It is important not just to look at the income tax costs of living in France but the French social security costs, as it is the latter that are often much higher and can catch out Brit retirees in France.
-
Julie,your very good example highlights what has happened to a large number of Brits with properties in France and Spain, in that they cannot sell as their properties do not appeal to local buyers. This is especially relevant in France where Brits tend to go for older rural properties, whereas the French prefer new properties in suburban areas nearer job opportunities, that are inexpensive to heat and maintain.
-
When French property priceswere appreciating there was a degree in logic in buying rather than renting aproperty in France. However, with French property prices depreciating (OECDrecently said French property prices were still 29% overvalued.) and forecastto do continue to decline for the foreseeable future, careful thought needs tobe given, especially as to whether or not you should keep a foot in the UKproperty market. As statistically it is likely you will eventually return tothe UK as most Brit retirees in France and Spain tend to do, usually because ofmissing family, illness, infirmity or death of a partner. Another considerationis that the £ is strengthening against the Euro and whilst that is good newsfor those with a UK source pension it means you get less £ for your Euros ifyou sell your French property and want to return to the UK property market.
My advice would be at thevery least to bide your time if you are not looking to retire for a few years,as the risk in rushing to buy a property now, is that if it turns out yousubsequently bought in the wrong place and want to move, selling could be verydifficult without taking a substantive loss in the current French property market,especially in the price bracket you have budgeted for. One of the reasons a lotof Brits who retire to France often look to move after a few years is that the winterclimate is much harsher than expected, or the property is just too big tomanage as one gets older.
In summary, for most Britsretiring to France it is not a forever move and whilst I am sure you will havea fantastic retirement in France, it is prudent to have an exit strategy forthe day that personal circumstances change and a move back to the UK, however reluctantly,maybe the sensible thing to do.
-
idun, non EU residents can only claim back TVA on goods exported outside the EU and most shops in France now have a minimum spend requirement for them to do the paperwork. Then the processing company who deal with the reclaim take a fee that seems to get bigger and bigger each year. Still worth doing but you don't get 20% back because of the fees charged by the reclaim company, most of which seem to be in Slovenia for some reason!
-
I know ofa lady in the UK who is in the situation of having to contribute towards herparents nursing care in France, and even though she is on a low wage and cannotreally afford it, she does not complain and dutifully coughs up. But I do thinkit is unfair as it is adversely impacting her ability to save for herretirement and as her children also live in the UK she won’t have any recourseto them for her nursing home costs in the future!
One wouldlike to think that foreign pensioners who can afford to retire to France budgetfor the eventual cost of nursing home care in that country, so as not to becomean undue burden on their children or the French State, but I fear many if notmost don’t and are unaware of the liability trap waiting for their children.
-
Jo, dare I say a lot of Brits and French would probably jump at the first opportunity to move to Canada if they could, cold winters aside, but as I am sure you are aware Canada has a very strict immigration policy and there is no retiree visa for EU citizens moving to France as far as I am aware.
London has a very large fast growing French population, as an increasing number of young French professionals move to the UK for better job prospects due to the poor economic situation in France. Curious to know whether Francophone Canada is experiencing a similar influx of French nationals?
-
Jo and Rich, the situation in France is no different in that the health care
system whilst good has become increasingly unaffordable for the government andis one of the contributory factors to the current French dire economic situation,as a result of which it cannot keep up with ever increasing demand and standardsof care are beginning to suffer.Believe me Canada is a utopia compared to the deteriorating economic and worrying
political situation in France, so don’t think the grass is greener on the otherside of the fence! -
Interesting comment that people with dementia losetheir second language capability earlier than their first language, as if thatis the case it is a consideration as towhether or not one would want to spend ones declining years in a foreign nursinghome if communication became a problem much sooner, as compared to being in anursing home that could speak your first language.
As for the economic migrant point, it can work bothways, as if you are dealing with a pensioner for example who moves to France onlyafter retirement and lives on a relatively small pension income and paysminimal or no French tax and cotisations on their UK pension, is it fair forthe French State to pick up the cost of providing nursing home and ancillarycare for elderly expats, or should it be the UK where the retiree has paid alifetime of tax and national insurance contributions, as would be the case formedical costs under the S1 agreement. This I gather is something several of thelarger EU countries are currently looking at a result of which it is likelytighter rules for inactifs will be introduced restricting access to benefits intheir adopted country of retirement.
The liability of non-French children to pay fortheir retired parents nursing home costs in France is contentious, especiallywhere the children are estranged and or there has been an abusive parentalrelationship. Also I am sure there have been circumstances where this has ledto adult children in the UK putting undue pressure on retired expat parents inFrance to come back to the UK when nursing home care is required.
-
Morocco is becoming an increasingly popular retiree andwinter sun destination, especially for the French. Reasons being it ispolitically stable, French speaking, relatively safe, inexpensive and easy and cheap to get to being served bythe low cost carriers. The French keepit to themselves as they probably don’t want all us Brits descending on mass!
-
For retirees looking to retire abroad health care is one ofthe biggest considerations and often overlooked, as understandably mostcountries are reluctant to allow a retiree immigrant to join their governmentfunded health system that they have not financially contributed to during theirworking lives, unless there is a reciprocal funding agreement with theimmigrants home country, as operates within the EU. So retiring abroad is usuallyonly a practical consideration whilst you have reasonably good health and can affordto privately fund your health care, unless you are an EU citizen retiringwithin the EU.
-
I would not discount the option of returning to the UK as a large part of
the equation must be how integrated is your friend into French life. If shedoes not speak the language and finds herself isolated and struggling, wherewould she prefer to be under the circumstances. If she has been in France arelatively short period of time and would prefer to be back in the UK, whereshe might get more support from friends and family then that might be theanswer.Also although her partner is estranged from his child that is probably
another factor, as notwithstanding if it was me, I would not want to burden mychildren with my nursing costs, if theywere struggling financially themselves. -
Hi Jo,
Welcome to the forum.
As non EU citizens you have two majorconsiderations that do not affect other members of the forum who are mostly EUcitizens and that is to stay in France for more than ninety days you will needa long stay visa and private medical insurance. ( I am presuming when you sayyou are French Canadian you come from the French speaking part of Canada, butdo not hold French nationality?)
As a retiree you should beable to obtain a French long stay visa which are aimed at wealthy non EUretirees, but be aware employment is prohibited and you have to demonstratesufficient means to live without the need to work and that you have fullycomprehensive private medical insurance, which can be problematical if eitherof you have pre-existing health conditions such as high blood pressure. A morerecent long stay French visa requirement is that you have to undertake acomprehensive medical.
EU citizen retirees moving withinthe EU including to France are covered by an EU reciprocal agreement wherebytheir home EU country pays the other EU country where they are retiring fortheir health care under what is called an S1, subject to them having asufficient social security contribution record in their EU home country, whichI think is normally ten years. So even if you can get EU citizenship throughancestry you won’t qualify unless you have worked in the EU for ten years.
For retirees the private medicalinsurance issue is a biggy, because once you get north of sixty finding costeffective insurance becomes increasingly difficult and the development of aserious health condition can lead to the renewal of insurance being denied orpremiums becoming prohibitively expensive. Hence why in the USA you haveMedicare for retirees and Canada and most of the EU have a government fundedhealth system.
-
In the Var air conditioningin the bedrooms at least is a necessity, if you want to get a proper night’ssleep in high summer. That said recent summers have not been too hot, but itlooks like we could be on course for a hot one this year, which is a bit of amixed blessing as the Var is very prone to serious forest fires duringprolonged hot and dry spells.
Down on the Cote D’Azurrecent winters have been very wet and seem to be part of a climate change trendso I would take the historical winter sunshine records with a pinch of salt. So,if mild sunny winters and reduced heating bills are a requirement for you, Ithink the whole of France is too far north and you need to get much furthersouth. I believe a lot of French retirees go to Morocco to winter?
-
Pat, Cannes is in the Alpes-Maritime, but yes you are right in that nearer the coast the more expensive property tends to get. As for Jonny, now that he has retired I guess he will be leaving France as quickly as possible to more friendly tax climes back in the UK and a lucrative job commentating on TV!
-
Welcome to the Forum. Just to encore what Norman has said in that you are doing absolutely the right thing, especially as French property prices are forecast to continue to decline for the forseeable future and if you buy in the wrong place selling can therefore be a challenge and very expensive. Ideally, you should have kept a foot on the UK property ladder, as statistically you are likely to return to the UK eventually and you will probably find yourself priced out of the UK property market, but I accept not everyone can afford to keep a property in the UK. Another consideration is that the Euro is also forecast to decline in value as the year progresses, so would recommend getting advice as to when is likely to be a good time to sell your £'s.
-
Well I am in the Var down on the coast where I have had ahouse for over ten years. Inland the winters can get very cold and summersexceedingly hot, so would recommend you visit the region in all seasons beforecommitting. If I am honest I have been disappointed with the climate as thereis no doubt the weather has become a lot wetter and more unsettled between lateOctober and early May in recent years and you are affected by the Mistral.
Here's different - France to Oz...
in Making the Move From Outside the EU
Posted